Waldorf Chemistry

A recent post on one of the Waldorf homeschooling email groups I subscribe to reminded me of this wonderful book on teaching chemistry using a Waldorf approach.

Waldorf teachers use a phenomenological approach in teaching the sciences. So rather than reading about a particular concept and then conducting an experiment to prove it true, Waldorf students conduct the demonstrations first, observe them and then see if a conclusion arises.

This approach makes the teaching of chemistry a much simpler task than it seems. We don’t need to abstractly learn concepts and the physical processes behind them. We just need to do things and observe. It’s really lots of fun.

This book by David Mitchell goes through the demonstrations you’ll conduct throughout 7th and 8th grades, along with the conclusions you and your students may come to. His instructions are just clear enough without feeling pedantically step-by-step. I particularly appreciated his instructions for building a lime kiln. Just mentioning it brings back such wonderful memories.

Have fun with chemistry in the upper grades!

Oh, I just realized that my Amazon link sells this book for over $100. Find it here at the Rudolf Steiner Bookstore for $26.95. While I was there checking it our I also found that they sell Mikko Bojarsky’s science handbooks! Mikko’s work is positively golden! The best Waldorf science guides on the planet!

Really Good Mainstream Math Resources

Though there are a lot of great Waldorf math resources, I sometimes found that I needed a little more than what I found there. Waldorf resources are great for detailing how to go about explaining a concept holistically, but when you just need a whole slew of problems for practice, mainstream resources are the way to go. Here are my recommendations.

Elementary and Middle School Mathematics by John van de Walle — Okay, so this isn’t a mainstream book with a whole slew of problems, but it is an incredibly good book that takes a holistic, sensible approach to math, unlike anything I’ve seen in other mainstream resources. It so clearly builds upon knowledge and content that the children already know, helping you, as the teacher, to increase your students’ number sense, rather than simply increasing their dexterity with juggling numbers. As a result, they’ll know why a certain “trick” works, as well as how to implement it with ease. It’s pricey, but it will take you from the very beginning, right up through algebra, so it’s worth it.

Key to Fractions by the Key Curriculum Press — The “Key to . . .” series is really wonderful. Though it does not focus on the content in a holistic, developmental way, it does break down the information in very easily digested chunks and it provides A LOT of practice with each concept. I had my students complete the Key to Fractions series, as well as the Key to Decimals series. We did this work not in the midst of the block but waited until the following year, using these books as review. This way the fresh, imaginative approach to the content held sway during the block while the sometimes tedious practice came later. I used the Key to Algebra books for my own preparation in teaching Algebra in 7th grade. For students who struggle with a concept, these books just can’t be beat. They’re also quite affordable (a little more than $3 per book, there are usually four books in each series.)

Saxon Math — The Saxon Math series of books are great for practice. Each book covers a wide breadth of material and gives LOTS of practice problems. One of the best things is that within each lesson practice problems from the previous lessons’ material is incorporated so your students will not learn something one week and forget it the next. I do sometimes wish these books gave more problems that dealt exclusively with the new material for each lesson, but for staying in practice with many different types of problems, Saxon is great. I have experience with the Saxon books for the older set — from about 4th grade and up. I understand that there are books out there for younger children, too, but look at them carefully. To me, there is nothing more important in those younger years than building strong number sense. Saxon does not do this very well, in my opinion, so I would not use it for presenting new material, particularly with younger children. But this does not discount it’s merit for providing a wealth of material for practice problems.

A Resource for Singing Games and Dances

I guess music is on my mind these days. I’ve been going through my music resources a lot these days and having a lot of fun finding songs I had never discovered before.

This week I was asked to bring some activity to our school’s Parent Council meeting. I taught them one of the songs and dances in this great book.

Singing Games and Playparty Games by Richard Chase – This book has fabulously clear instructions for dances and games that you can do to music with a group. Tonight I taught the parents the first song in the book called “Turn the Glasses Over.” People always enjoy getting together, moving and singing in a coordinated way (even if they may seem reluctant at first.)

The songs in the book are simple, familiar melodies so they’re quick and easy to learn. The dances have really great, clear instructions with good accompanying illustrations. You’ll easily be able to follow them to lead a dance yourself. Bring one to your child’s next birthday party and have fun!

Games Book Recommendations

I know it isn’t bright and sunny everywhere, but in my neck of the woods spring arrived a bit early and it has me feeling like getting outside and moving! As a teacher, leading games was never my strong suit, but as my teaching years went on I appreciated more and more the value of moving with my students, especially when a good (sometimes competitive) game was involved.

I often found the key to a successful games class was knowing when to bring a new and exciting game. With everything else that teachers need to do, the temptation to keep playing an old familiar game is strong, but there are some great resources out there with plenty of ideas for games, so it doesn’t have to be too difficult to come up with something new.

The New Games Book – A friend recently loaned me this book and I love it! It probably has about 50 different games, all with clear explanations and photographs to go with them. The photos really helped me because I often have a hard time visualizing games when they are explained with words. The book is broken down into sections determined by the number of players required for each game, which is an infinitely sensible way to organize the book. Waldorf teachers usually teach children a game with a story, or sometimes just a little image for the children to hold onto while they are playing the game. Many of the games in this book include an imagination along with them (catch the dragon’s tail, for example) but for others you’ll need to come up with your own imagination. Some of the games are old favorites that we all played when we were kids, and others are so new and different that I’ve never seen them played anywhere. You’ll have to use your intuition when it comes to determining which games are appropriate for the ages of your children. When in doubt it’s a good idea to stick with more collaborative games in the younger grades, increasing the level of competition and individuality as the children get older.

Games Children Play – This is one of the standard Waldorf games books, and it is quite good. If you’re not sure about trusting your intuition when it comes to determining appropriate games, this book can give you a guide. It follows the pedagogical decisions about appropriate games in a very logical way, even giving some explanation in each section. The book is broken down according to age, which makes it the perfect companion to The New Games Book. One flaw of this book, though, is that I found that it didn’t give enough games. My students and I ran through the games in each section and I found that they needed more new games. Still, this is a great book to have, and close to essential for helping to learn the pedagogical reasons behind choosing appropriate games.

Child’s Play 1 and 2 – I don’t have much personal experience with this book, but I’ve seen it on every shelf and it seems to be the “other” Waldorf games book. It seems that in my cursory glance through it I found that the games were most suited to the younger grades. If any of you have experience with it please post in the comments.

Have fun and get out there and move with your students!

Eighth Grade Story Resources

Okay, we finally made it! Waldorf schools are probably the only place where people still tell stories to eighth graders. My students loved a good story and I could still captivate them with a gripping tale right up to graduation. The history curriculum in eighth grade is “Revolutions” and traditionally the French, American and Industrial Revolutions are covered. Some teachers in the US have narrowed it to cover only US history in eighth grade. Though I think it is important to stick with the “revolutions” theme, I can understand the impulse to stick with just US history, as there is so much material to cover. One of the things I regret about my eighth grade year is that we only got through the Civil War in the timeline of US history. When I compare that to the breadth of US history I covered in my own education, I find it sorely lacking. But, we must make compromises, and my students will get a healthy dose of US history in high school.

So, what resources to use?

The Age of Revolution by Charles Kovacs – By now you should know that anything Kovacs gets my highest stamp of approval. Again, this book is great for covering the content in a succinct way. Following this book you could easily make your history blocks economical when it comes to time. It might even be possible to cover the Industrial, French and American Revolutions in one three week block, and then dedicate the second history block to the rest of American history. Hmmm, I might do it that way myself next time. The sacrifice, of course, is having the time to go into depth, but much depth is gained simply by working in blocks and immersing yourself in history for three full weeks. It could very well be enough.

1776 by David McCullough – This was another over-the-summer read for me that really helped me when it came to building a feeling for the American Revolution. It goes into so much detail that it’s hard to use as a resource for teaching directly, but there were definitely parts of it that I used for telling stories during the block. Looking back, if I had taken better notes during my reading of it I would have been able to teach from it very well, but instead I lazily read it by the lake during the summer, absorbing the feeling of the revolution, not so much the details. Still, I highly recommend it.

John Adams by David McCullough – Okay, I confess, I watched the mini-series. But it was so good, and you know when you’re teaching and you really want to watch a movie but you can’t justify spending the time? That’s what historical dramas are perfect for. Actually, watching the mini-series really helped in teaching this block. I took my telling of the Boston Massacre straight from the movie. Terrible, I know.

To Kill a Mockingbird by Harper Lee – You must, and I mean MUST, assign this to your eighth graders to read. It fits in so beautifully with American History but it is also such a compelling story. Every eighth grader should be presented with Atticus Finch as the representative upright human being. I noticed my students sit up a little bit straighter in their chairs after reading this book, and I myself stood before them with greater presence. Makes me want to reread it now.

For this block I also used countless resources from the public library. Great biographies to tell include Benjamin Franklin, Sojourner Truth, Fredrick Douglass, Abraham Lincoln, Harriet Tubman, Abigail Adams. . . . the list goes on. I found the biographies in the juvenile section of the library perfectly acceptable for these stories. AWSNA has recently put out a book on biographies to tell in 8th grade, but I’m not familiar enough with it to recommend it.

Seventh Grade Story Resources

Continuing with my series of story resources for the mythology/history curriculum through the grades, here is my entry for grade seven.

The Waldorf history curriculum for seventh grade centers around the dynamic and enlightening time of the Renaissance. Here are the few resources that I used extensively when I taught this block.

Copernicus by Heinz Sponsel – Using this book, I read and retold the story of Copernicus during our Astronomy block. It has a lovely familiar tone and tells much of the story during the time when Copernicus is the same age as the students are themselves. It was definitely the kind of book I could read through myself and tell directly from the book. It would also make a nice class reader for use during the Astronomy block.

The World Awakes by Polly Schoyer Brooks – If you can get your hands on this out of print book you should grab it, fast. It is absolutely worth its weight in gold and is THE resource to have for teaching the Renaissance in seventh grade. I’ve been keeping my eye our for an affordable copy for awhile now, I borrowed it from a fellow teacher when I taught the block. It lays out the information to teach in a systematic yet beautifully imaginative way. The stories are so imaginative and lovely that they can be told straight from the book. The rich content of the Renaissance can be so overwhelming that it is nice to have a resource that has already sifted through all of that content and brought just the essential points. Definitely a must have.

The Agony and the Ecstasy by Irving Stone – I read this book the summer before seventh grade and I loved how it gave a feeling for the time of the Renaissance. It presents the story of Michaelangelo in a very thorough (and long) but completely engaging way. It is definitely not the kind of book you can read in the midst of teaching the block and hope to teach from it, but read it before the school year begins to capture the feeling for the time. I was grateful to have had this rich window into the personality of Michaelangelo so when it came time to teach his story I felt like I was telling the children about someone I knew personally. If you’re pressed for time it definitely is not the most economical book to read (Michaelangelo would be taught in a one or two day lesson) but because it does such a lovely job of infusing the reader with the spirit of the Renaissance, especially the artistic work that was happening in Italy, it is a good read. And, like I said, I found it completely engaging on those long summer days before the school year properly began.

I’m sure that Kovacs also has a book that addresses the history curriculum of seventh grade, but if he does, I did not use it. I love all of his books, so if you come across one, I can’t help but assume it is to be recommended.

Coming soon, the culmination of the history curriculum in grade eight.

One Stand-Out History Resource

Dear readers, thank you so much for bearing with me through my spotty posting record. Lots has been happening here — visiting schools, watching for the next adventure that looms on the horizon.

I’ve promised (for weeks) to post resources for 7th and 8th grade history stories, but before I do that I wanted to share a book that I absolutely love.

A Little History of the World by E.H. Gombrich

If you are someone like me, who has huge gaps in your own history education, this is the book to read. In about 300 easy-to-read pages it sweeps through the entire course of human history. It definitely  has a European focus, which was something I appreciated as my own education included hardly any history of Europe. The chapters read like little stories and though it is often sparse on detail, it brings the major points of each epoch in a beautifully thought-provoking way.

Because of its lack of detail it is of limited usefulness as a teaching resource  (meaning you likely won’t tell stories straight from it), but it is invaluable for summarizing and capturing the essential points of human history. For this reason I consider it my most essential history resource and I would not want to teach Waldorf history without it. I would recommend reading it at the beginning of your Waldorf journey, so you have a clear picture of where your history studies will take you as you travel through the grades. Then, reread it before beginning fifth grade when the study of history properly begins. Then, before each grade, read the section that pertains to the era of history you’ll be addressing that year. Gombrich’s voice will become a cozy and familiar presence. I found that this book positively shaped my teaching of history and I am infinitely grateful to have discovered it as a resource.

Eric Fairman’s A Path of Discovery

A Path of Discovery is a curriculum resource written by Australian Waldorf teacher Eric Fairman. I have found his work to be inspiring and full of great ideas. From Bob and Nancy’s Bookshop website,

Eric Fairman is a delightfully creative (and amazingly well-organized!) Waldorf grade school teacher in Australia who has done us all a great service by publishing the lesson notes he has kept through the years. In this as in all the Path of Discovery books, you will find suggested lessons, examples of ways of presenting the subject matter, verses, poems, songs – and, most importantly, a priceless amount of support and inspiration.

He has written a volume for each grade, in addition to an overview of the math curriculum and a book titled Food, Nutrition and Health that is dedicated to the eighth grade chemistry block. The books are affordably priced (just $21.00 each) and provide a wonderful framework for each block.

When I taught 7th grade I used A Path of Discovery as a resource and found it quite helpful when it came to planning the block. Though there is a fair amount of information in each book, I did not find the information so thorough that it could exist on its own. Instead, I mostly used A Path of Discovery as a planning resource and then I gathered information from other resources to provide the content of the block. All through my teaching I found this to be necessary. There were certain books that were excellent at providing the framework for a block, giving me enough information to know what to look for at the library. If you’re looking for a book that you’ll be able to open up to page one and begin teaching from, A Path of Discovery is not it. I never found it satisfying to teach in this manner, though, and I enjoyed the search for information.

What A Path of Discovery does very well, though, is provide inspiring, interesting ways to work with the material. As Fairman describes his experience teaching the block to his students he describes activities that they did that helped to bring the material in a new, interesting and holistic way. There are any number of books at the public library that can provide factual information for every block, but resources that inspire new and creative ideas of working with material are few and far between and these are the Waldorf-specific resources that are worth spending a little extra on.

At least in the upper grades, A Path of Discovery does not provide material on every block that must be taught in the year. The seventh grade book, for example, covers Chemistry, Physiology, and Physics, in addition to child development information, verses and poems, a reading list, block test samples, a bibliography and information on a few other various topics including morse code, Pythagoras and Thales. It does not, though, cover Astronomy, Algebra, History or Creative Writing, blocks that are important and should be covered in seventh grade. What it does cover, though, it does quite well and if you are a teacher who finds the sciences to be a weak spot, A Path of Discovery can help you find the new, inspiring and interesting way to bring the sciences to your students.

Top 5 “Introduction to Waldorf” books

There are a handful of books that make great introductions to Waldorf education. A couple of these books have been my go-to gift choice for new parents, or friends who are exploring education options.

You Are Your Child’s First Teacher by Rahima Baldwin-Dancy

This Waldorf Education classic was my first Waldorf book. It has been the first Waldorf book of innumerable parents. My own 14-year-old copy is tattered and worn and has been loaned out countless times. It’s relevent for ages birth-7, though it really focuses on the first 3 years. It beautifully describes a basic Waldorf approach to child-rearing, covering all of the basic parenting topics. The section on the care and protection that a newborn requires is particularly well-done, beginning with the title, ”What was birth like for your baby?” It’s a lovely way to begin thinking about the care that a newborn needs.

The book doesn’t stop with the newborn, though. It goes on to provide a guide for artistic living, including tips for inspiring that creativity in your children.

The best part, though, is that it doesn’t scream “I am a Waldorf book!” so you can give it to friends who may not be interested in Waldorf education and they’ll still get a lot out of it. (And maybe by the end be convinced that Waldorf education is the way to go!)

Understanding Waldorf Education by Jack Petrash

This is a great book! It has sections on preschool, grade school and high school. It has a section for parents and for teachers. It’s a very practical book, but incredibly inspiring, too. The final chapter, called “Towards a Truly Human Education” is the best part and it does a wonderful job of describing what is truly unique about Waldorf education and how it is truly the antidote to so many of the world’s ills. Love. This. Book. I’m putting it back on my nightstand for a reread.

School as a Journey, by Torin Finser

This book is written by Finser, a Waldorf class teacher. He describes his experience teaching a class from 1st through 8th grade. In addition to giving a good feeling about what it is like for a student and teacher to be together for 8 years, he does an amazing job of capturing the mood and feeling of each grade. A chapter is dedicated to each grade, which really helps to create that mood. When I was teaching I often printed out the chapter devoted to the grade I was teaching and passed it out to parents. The book is incredibly readable as you get to know Finser as a teacher and even some of his students. It includes two appendices that gives some of the theoretical background behind Waldorf education. Any parent considering Waldorf education for his or her child should read this book — I’ve given it as a gift many times.

Beyond the Rainbow Bridge, by Barbara J. Patterson

This is a very sweet, inspiring book that covers the beauty of early childhood. It makes a lovely companion to You Are Your Child’s First Teacher and with sections on play, discipline, rhythm and the child’s senses, it is useful in an inspiring way. I remember when I first got this book I read it cover to cover in a night, by flashlight in our family bed. Great book!

These books are so high on my list of the Waldorf canon that I am hard-pressed to come up with a fifth book! Perhaps there are only 4 top introduction to Waldorf books. I’d love to hear, though, if there’s one I’m missing. Ideas? What’s the favorite book on your Waldorf shelf?

Complete Curricula

As a teacher in a Waldorf school, I actually have little experience with any of the complete Waldorf curriculum resources that are out there. In my training we were taught that ideally the teacher crafts the curriculum entirely from scratch, following Rudolf Steiner’s guidelines and his or her own intuition about the students’ needs. This is not always possible, though, and with the tremendous amount of work required of the Waldorf teacher, I did, every now and then, use one of these resources in my work, and it was a great time-saver. These resources are even more valuable for the homeschooling parent who has undertaken the arduous task of teaching multiple children, usually without undergoing a training. Here’s a list of the curricula that I know of. Individual reviews will follow.

Live Education! – reviewed here.

Oak Meadow

Christopherus – see first grade reviewed here.

A Little Garden Flower

Waldorf Without Walls

Eric Fairman’s A Path of Discovery – reviewed here

Eugene Schwartz’ Millenial Child

Enki Education

If you have used any of these resources and would like to share your experience here, please contact me at meredith@waldorfreviews.com.